Posts from December 2022 (9)

The BBC: Hershey sued in US over metal in dark chocolate claim. 

This is a slight variation on normal headline grammar:  Hershey isn’t being sued over something they claimed; they are being sued because Consumer Reports claims to have found surprisingly high concentrations of lead and cadmium in dark chocolate from a wide range of manufacturers, small and large, organic and conventional, fair-trade and … whatever the opposite of that is.  The cadmium seems to come from the soil — chocolate eaters are on the wrong end of phytoremediation here — and the experts don’t actually know where the lead comes from. Hershey is being sued because they’re a potentially rewarding target, not because they are more at fault than other chocolate makers.

So, how bad is it? Consumer Reports say that the heavy-metal concentrations exceed health standards if you eat an ounce (like, 30g) every day. To get this result, they used the strictest health thresholds they could find: as they phrase it, “CR’s scientists believe that California’s levels are the most protective available”.  We can look at how California computed its threshold (MADL) for cadmium — at least, how it did in 2001; it’s possible there’s a stricter threshold that I haven’t found on Google.  The procedure was to take the highest concentration with no observed adverse effects in animals, scale it by weight, and divide by 1000 for safety.  With cadmium, they didn’t have a no-effect study, they only had a study showing adverse effects, so they put in an extra factor of 10 to account for that.  So, the threshold we’re comparing to is 10,000 times lower than the lowest concentration definitely shown to be harmful.  The California law doesn’t say it’s dangerous to exceed this threshold; it says that if you’re under this threshold you’re so safe that you don’t have to warn consumers that there’s cadmium present. (PDF)

For chemicals known to the state to cause reproductive toxicity, an exemption from the warning requirement is provided by the Act when a person in the course of doing business is able to demonstrate that an exposure for which the person is responsible will have no observable reproductive effect, assuming exposure at 1,000 times the level in question

Presumably the same is basically true of lead.  Now, lead and cadmium are well worth avoiding, even at levels not specifically known to be harmful. Lead, in particular, seems to have small adverse effects even at very low concentrations.  But the level of risk from doses anywhere in the vicinity the California MADL is, by careful design, very low.

We can look at NZ dietary exposures to cadmium, in the incredibly-detailed NZ Total Diet Study (PDF). We’re averaging about 5.2 ug per kg of bodyweight per month for women, 6.6 for men, and 12 for 5-6year old kids. The provisional monthly tolerable dose given in that report is 25.

Our numbers are a bit  higher than France and Australia, a bit lower than Hong Kong, and about the same as Italy.  If you take the hypothetical 58kg woman used in the California regulatory maths, she would consume about 10 ug/day of cadmium. The California limit is 4.1 and the NZ limit is 48. So, an ounce of high-cadmium dark chocolate per day, if it’s, say, twice the California limit, is a significant fraction of the typical cadmium consumption, but well under any levels actually known to have health risks.

For years, the StatsChat rule on dark chocolate has been “If you’re eating it primarily for the health benefits, you’re doing it wrong”. That still seems to hold.

Team Ratings for Round 14

The basic method is described on my Department home page.
Here are the team ratings prior to this week’s games, along with the ratings at the start of the season.

Performance So Far

So far there have been 62 matches played, 40 of which were correctly predicted, a success rate of 64.5%.
Here are the predictions for last week’s games.

Predictions for Round 14

Here are the predictions for Round 14. The prediction is my estimated expected points difference with a positive margin being a win to the home team, and a negative margin a win to the away team.

Team Ratings for Week 11

The basic method is described on my Department home page.
Here are the team ratings prior to this week’s games, along with the ratings at the start of the season.

Performance So Far

So far there have been 77 matches played, 60 of which were correctly predicted, a success rate of 77.9%.
Here are the predictions for last week’s games.

Predictions for Week 11

Here are the predictions for Week 11. The prediction is my estimated expected points difference with a positive margin being a win to the home team, and a negative margin a win to the away team.

Team Ratings for Round 14

The basic method is described on my Department home page.
Here are the team ratings prior to this week’s games, along with the ratings at the start of the season.

Performance So Far

So far there have been 91 matches played, 65 of which were correctly predicted, a success rate of 71.4%.
Here are the predictions for last week’s games.

Predictions for Round 14

Here are the predictions for Round 14. The prediction is my estimated expected points difference with a positive margin being a win to the home team, and a negative margin a win to the away team.

Stuff has a new fact-check column, “The Whole Truth”, and there’s a good example with discussion of youth crime trends, by James Halpin.

The graphs are just the sort of thing I use and recommend: enough history and (where appropriate) enough context to see what trends are just continuing and where things might have changed

It’s clear that the orange line in the left panel is different from basically everything else.  It looks as though the blue line might be going up, but it’s clearly still lower than it was in recent years.

That is, one category of crime in one age group is up.  Overall, robberies and burglaries, even those specifically committed by young people, aren’t increasing, but these vehicle crimes are.  They go on to say that ram-raids by young people are up; the absolute numbers are small, but these are serious crimes, with damage out of proportion to the amount stolen. It’s unlikely to be reporting bias — again, these are serious crimes that would usually be reported.

The data can’t really support a general ‘kids today’ narrative, but there is a real, specific, problem.

• I’ve often complained about misleading bar graphs in reporting electoral opinion polls. 1News just punted on the whole issue with this:
  
• The cost of the Meola Road rebuild, $47.5 million, has been inaccurately portrayed as the cost of the bike lane that’s a minor component of it. Twitter user @ArcCyclist got the actual breakdown from the Council:
  
  While I’m at it, I do want to note one way it’s a bad table: the cycleway number is given to whole dollars, with everything else given in cents, so it looks even smaller than it really is. You usually don’t want to delete trailing zeroes in a table.
• The ESR Covid wastewater dashboard is now at poops.nz. Yes, really.
• There’s a new “technical report for future UK Chief Medical Officers, Government Chief Scientific Advisers, National Medical Directors and public health leaders in a pandemic” from the UK. Even if you aren’t among that exalted company, some of the information may be useful to public citizens as well
• The Ministry of Health is seeking public comment on something it wrote about ‘precision health’. There might be StatsChat readers who have reckons.
• Eric Crampton notes that cost-benefit ratios for transport projects are defined in an idiosyncratic way that makes them hard to compare either with each other or with non-transport projects.
• The first drug to convincingly delay Type I diabetes onset has been approved. The average benefit is about two years, and the treatment will be marketed at US$200,000.  Cost-effectiveness research suggests this is way more than it’s worth for most people, even in the US where insulin for Type I diabetes is very expensive.

Team Ratings for Week 10

The basic method is described on my Department home page.
Here are the team ratings prior to this week’s games, along with the ratings at the start of the season.

Performance So Far

So far there have been 69 matches played, 53 of which were correctly predicted, a success rate of 76.8%.
Here are the predictions for last week’s games.

Predictions for Week 10

Here are the predictions for Week 10. The prediction is my estimated expected points difference with a positive margin being a win to the home team, and a negative margin a win to the away team.

Team Ratings for Round 13

The basic method is described on my Department home page.
Here are the team ratings prior to this week’s games, along with the ratings at the start of the season.

Performance So Far

So far there have been 84 matches played, 62 of which were correctly predicted, a success rate of 73.8%.
Here are the predictions for last week’s games.

Predictions for Round 13

Here are the predictions for Round 13. The prediction is my estimated expected points difference with a positive margin being a win to the home team, and a negative margin a win to the away team.

Team Ratings for Round 13

The basic method is described on my Department home page.
Here are the team ratings prior to this week’s games, along with the ratings at the start of the season.

Performance So Far

So far there have been 57 matches played, 37 of which were correctly predicted, a success rate of 64.9%.
Here are the predictions for last week’s games.

Predictions for Round 13

Here are the predictions for Round 13. The prediction is my estimated expected points difference with a positive margin being a win to the home team, and a negative margin a win to the away team.