May 16, 2014
On keeping your own score…
“People and institutions cannot keep their own score accurately. Metrics soon become targets and then pitches, and are thereby gamed, corrupted, misreported, fudged…
Examples: premature revenue recognition, Libor rates, beating the quarterly forecast by a single penny, terrorist attacks prevented, Weapons of Mass Destruction, number of Twitter followers, all body counts (crowd sizes, civilians blown up). Sometimes call the Principle of Lake Woebegone, where all children are above average.”
– Edward Tufte
There is an interesting story at the Guardian in their “Secret Teacher” blogs about how students become subservient to targets …
“Secret Teacher: education writes off students in the name of targets – Would you encourage parents of a low-achieving student to change schools so your results weren’t dragged down?”
http://www.theguardian.com/teacher-network/teacher-blog/2014/may/17/secret-teacher-education-students-targets
11 years ago